No advice about trampoline, I’m afraid, as our back yard wouldn’t fit one. But I would go with a net if I was getting one as when P and L went to trampolining in a gym the teacher wouldn’t do the class unless there was at least one adult on each side to act as catchers if necessary!

Don’t know anything about those two makes, mine was a similar cost for a smaller one though but bought as being a “proper” trampoline make rather than a “play” make IYSWIM, so after researching was told it was the safest because of that. I didn’t buy a net though as all my research showed that a net makes children less naturally careful and therefore more prone to falling off/accidents and had heard of children slipping inbetween net and trampoline and getting very hurt. I did probably over research though as was anxious to get something that lasted!